top of page

The Immigration and Asylum Bill Passes the Commons: What Happens Next in the Lords?

Writer: Hextons UK
Hextons UK
7 minutes ago
6 min read
House of Commons
House of Commons

The government's flagship immigration legislation has cleared its most significant parliamentary hurdle. On 17 November 2026, the Immigration and Asylum Bill passed its Third Reading in the House of Commons by 290 votes to 94—a majority of 196. It now moves to the House of Lords, where it faces detailed scrutiny, potential amendment, and the next chapter in a fiercely contested legislative process.


The vote was not without dissent. Fourteen Labour MPs voted against the Bill at Third Reading, including Diane Abbott, John McDonnell, and Nadia Whittome, signalling continued unease on the government's own backbenches about the direction of asylum and returns policy.


This blog explains what the Bill does, what happened in the Commons, what the Lords stage will involve, the objections that have been raised, and what it all means for anyone affected by the UK's immigration and asylum system.


1. What the Bill Does: The Key Measures


The Immigration and Asylum Bill is the legislative vehicle for the reforms set out in the government's November 2025 "Restoring Order and Control" statement. Its central provisions include:


A New Independent Immigration Appeals Authority (IIAA)


The Bill establishes a new Independent Immigration Appeals Authority to replace the First-tier Tribunal for most asylum and human rights appeals. The government describes it as delivering a "swift and fair appeals system" that can "scale to meet changing demand" and ensure cases "flow through quickly to removal where appeals are unsuccessful".


A Single "Core Protection" Model


The Bill replaces separate refugee status and humanitarian protection with a single "core protection" model. This simplifies the protection framework into one status for anyone who qualifies under the Refugee Convention or would face serious harm if returned.


Faster Removals: No Five-Day Notice


Currently, enforced returns can only take place after a minimum notice period of five working days. The Bill scraps this timeframe, giving immigration officers a six-month period to remove failed asylum seekers and illegal migrants before further notice is required.


Shorter Refugee Leave: Five Years to Two-and-a-Half


The Bill reduces the initial grant of leave for those given refugee status from five years to two-and-a-half years. This is one of the most contentious provisions, significantly extending the period of insecurity before a refugee can apply for settlement.


Article 8 and Modern Slavery Reforms


The Bill defines the application of Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights to ensure "the public interest carries proper weight" in immigration decisions. It also reforms the Modern Slavery system, introducing a "bad faith" definition to disqualify individuals who knowingly make dishonest claims or raise modern slavery information after being given notice of removal.


A Contribution Requirement


The Bill introduces a mechanism requiring asylum seekers receiving taxpayer-funded accommodation and support to contribute to those costs when they are financially able to do so.


2. The Commons Rebellion: What Happened


The Bill passed comfortably, but the 14 Labour rebels exposed the depth of internal disagreement. Bell Ribeiro-Addy argued that settlement could be "bought and flogged to the highest bidder" under the proposals, while Apsana Begum accused the government of "utter betrayal".


A backbench amendment by Neil Duncan-Jordan MP sought to broaden the care worker settlement exemption to other skilled workers. It was backed by Unison and Unite but was rejected by MPs. The government maintained that the exemption for care workers and non-degree public sector roles in health and education was "exceptional", justified by their service during Covid and beyond.


The rebellion did not defeat the Bill, but it signals that the Lords stage will be contested, and that the government may face further pressure to amend the settlement provisions.


3. What Happens Next in the Lords?


The Timetable


The Bill was introduced to the Lords on 18 November 2026, when it received its First Reading. The next key stage is Second Reading, where peers debate the general principles of the Bill. No date has yet been confirmed, but it is expected shortly.


After Second Reading, the Bill will proceed to Committee Stage, where peers scrutinise it line by line and can table amendments. This is where the most significant changes are likely to be proposed—particularly on refugee leave duration, the Article 8 provisions, and the modern slavery reforms.


The Lords' Role: Scrutiny and Potential Amendments


The Lords cannot veto the Bill, but it can amend it and delay its passage. If the Lords passes amendments, the Bill returns to the Commons, where MPs can accept, reject, or modify them. This process—known as "ping-pong"—can repeat until agreement is reached or the Bill is lost.


Given the breadth of opposition from human rights organisations, UNHCR, and the Equality and Human Rights Commission, the Lords is likely to see substantial amendments tabled, particularly on:

  • Refugee leave duration – critics argue that reducing leave to two-and-a-half years undermines integration and creates prolonged insecurity

  • Article 8 – concerns that the provisions weaken family life protections

  • Modern slavery – warnings that the "bad faith" definition will deter genuine victims from coming forward

  • Removal notice – objections to removing the five-day notice period


When Will It Become Law?


The Bill must pass the Lords and receive Royal Assent before it becomes law. The government has not set a target date, but given the contested nature of the provisions, the Lords stage could take several weeks or months. Realistically, Royal Assent is unlikely before early 2027.


4. The Objections: What the Critics Say


The Bill has drawn unusually broad criticism from legal, human rights, and refugee organisations.


Amnesty International UK


Amnesty has opposed the Bill, describing the government's approach as "politics as performance not problem solving" and warning that "several proposals are deeply alarming: from attempts to weaken protections for families and sideline long-established human rights obligations".


UNHCR


The UN refugee agency has published detailed observations assessing the Bill's compatibility with international refugee and human rights obligations. It examines reforms to asylum appeals, family life, protection status, and the interpretation of Refugee Convention provisions, and makes recommendations to strengthen procedural

safeguards, access to protection, family unity, and refugee integration.


The Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC)


The EHRC has raised "key human rights considerations" ahead of the Bill's Second Reading, questioning how the provisions interact with human rights protections.


Liberty


Liberty has warned that the Bill "risks weakening our right to family life" through its reforms to Article 8.


Modern Slavery Concerns


Parliamentary submissions have warned that the modern slavery provisions "pose a serious risk to victims and survivors of labour exploitation" and will "severely harm the UK's ability to identify and support victims of trafficking".


5. What This Means for You


If You Are an Asylum Seeker or Refugee


The Bill's provisions on refugee leave duration, removal notice, and appeals will directly affect your case. If you are currently in the asylum system or have recently been granted protection, understanding how the new rules—once enacted—will apply to you is essential.


If You Have an Article 8 or Family Life Claim


The Bill's Article 8 provisions are intended to make it harder to rely on family life grounds to resist removal. If you have a pending application or appeal based on Article 8, the changing legal framework may affect your strategy.


If You Are a Victim of Modern Slavery


The "bad faith" definition could affect your ability to access protections if you have not disclosed information early. If you are in this position, seeking advice before the Bill becomes law is critical.


If You Are an Employer or Sponsor


The Bill's contribution requirement and modern slavery reforms may affect your obligations and the way you handle disclosures from workers. The care worker settlement exemption—which survived the Commons vote—remains in place, but the broader settlement landscape is still shifting.


6. Key Takeaways

What

Detail

Commons vote

Passed Third Reading 290–94 on 17 November 2026

Labour rebellion

14 Labour MPs voted against

Next stage

House of Lords – First Reading 18 November 2026

Key measures

IIAA; single "core protection"; no five-day removal notice; refugee leave cut to 2.5 years; Article 8 reforms; modern slavery "bad faith" definition

Main objections

Amnesty, UNHCR, EHRC, Liberty, modern slavery experts

Likely Lords amendments

Refugee leave duration; Article 8; modern slavery; removal notice

Royal Assent

Not expected before early 2027


How Hextons Law Can Help


At Hextons Law, we are tracking the Immigration and Asylum Bill through every stage of its parliamentary passage. We can assist with:

  • Asylum and protection claims – advising on how the new "core protection" model may affect your case

  • Appeals – preparing for the transition to the new Independent Immigration Appeals Authority

  • Article 8 and family life applications – understanding the changing legal framework

  • Modern slavery cases – advising on the "bad faith" definition and how to protect your position

  • Refugee settlement planning – understanding the impact of shorter leave grants on your long-term status


If you are affected by the Bill—whether as an asylum seeker, refugee, family applicant, or employer—contact Hextons Law today for confidential, expert advice. The Bill has cleared the Commons, but the law has not yet changed. The time to understand your position is now.


This article is provided for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Immigration rules and legislation are subject to change, and specific legal advice should always be sought for your particular circumstances.


Hextons Law LTD
Hextons Law LTD

Comments


Family in Airport

Opening Hours

Mon - Fri: 9am - 5pm

(British Summer Time)

​​Saturday - ​ Sunday:  Off

Address

Bedford Heights,

Brickhill Dr,

Bedford

MK41 7PH

Hextons Law UK LLP

logo.png
bottom of page